Showing posts with label transport. Show all posts
Showing posts with label transport. Show all posts

Friday, 20 July 2007

is Myki the be all and end all for public transport

so...
Melbourne gets a new ticketing system in 2008 called myki [sounds like my key]. For the 1/2 billion $ the govt has allocated to this project just in set up costs, which are probably likely to increase before the poroject is delivered, I'm sure you could have almost made the entire public transport network free for the same cost.
Why are people using public transport held to ransom ?
I have a funny feeling that takeup will be slow - because its stored vale, it means that you have to treat it like a credit card. Unfortunately people don't currently store their public transport tickets in a safe way.
Also, if you choose not to register your card, if you lose it the credit is gone.
Thirdly, a system will calculate your best fare for the day. Wonder what kind of dispute process they will have if you disagree with what the system calculated the charge as, how will you know what day you used it, where you went etc. Why can't people continue to buy the tickets that they want to buy and if its cheaper to use another type of ticket then do so, if its more expensive then give them the option to not travel.
Me - I'll keep using the paper system thank you, until the bugs have been worked out.

Friday, 15 June 2007

airport checkin processes

over the last two weeks I had cause to fly every weekend .... and with different airlines.

Now airline 1 had a very easy to use web check in process, and as long as you have a computer printer handy you could print your boarding pass (assuming no luggage). Then all you needed to do was to rock on up to the airport 1/2 hr before you fly.

Airline 2 allowed you to change your seats but still wanted you to queue and check-in via normal hence you needing to be at the airport earlier than you would have to. This was true even if you had no luggage.

as a result I was miffed - why do i have to check in when I have no luggage - why can't I just go to an ATM like machine and print a boarding pass. Even better - why not use my mobile phone # which they have to send a boarding pass/barcode straight to my phone and let me just use my mobile to scan in (ok I would have to turn it off after boarded).

I certainly don't appreciate having my time wasted by having to be anywhere earlier than I need to be. This is not convient to me or how I live my life. Lucky I have a laptop else I wouldn't even be able to work at the airport and at least use my time effectively.

Whilst it may be a cheap airline, cheap checkin, don't they 1) look at what their competitors are doing 2) look at what their customers want or would make them an preferred carrier ??

Wednesday, 9 May 2007

public transport usage lately

Due to the removal of zone 3, and increases in fuel prices and also car parking rates more people seem to be using public transport in Melbourne to get to work.
As a result of this extra usage (around 20%) I've noticed the following:
  • have to get on train really early now to get a seat. Even trains with a 30 min trip departing at 7am have become standing room only, and then sardine city further in
  • a train at 8am with a 30 min trip seems to be packed when I am getting on
  • is there a limit for public safety for trains ? if every exit area is packed in like sardines is that breaching any OHS rules. Does our govt owe us all a duty of care?
  • Why is the network failing to cope (ie late or cancelled trains) when there should be plans to cater for this scenario. 20% is alot, but at the same time it's been something that should have been happening for quite a while. How many businesses can cope though, with a 20% jump in usage 'overnight'? Has their been a failure to plan for suburb and city growth and the effects on infrastructure
  • or are we going greener and considering the impact cars have
  • what happened to getting lifts with people/workmates/friends? Is it not knowing the person 'that well', people are to selfish, there is too much change and unpredictability, or people are working long hours.
  • there isn't there a CBD ticket - in reality this is just a short trip ticket for city workers or City livers who don't need a car. The only comparable ticket is a 'short trip' but this ticket is distance based rather than a time based. Note: this is the only distance ticket every other ticket is time based. Surely this is not just a revenue raiser :-0. Imagine being able to just get a ticket to get you round the city at lunchtime while you do errands that is quite cheap - say $1 for 2 hours. I think that it would be a great idea and cut back on fraud
  • why is it that the new smartcards are going to be point to point by default instead of what we know and already use. Point to point only works if a person only goes to work without anywhere else. Will smartcards be able to be topped up by the web the same way citylink works?

Public transport really seems like it's struggling now, so how is it going to cope in the future as we try to as a society wean ourselves off our car dependence?